In a Thought Leader piece in the February 2009 issue of Inside Knowledge, Neil Olonoff made a case for the importance of recognizing that all our knowledge is uncertain, that we in Knowledge Management should have no hesitation in admitting uncertainty, and since we “live in a world of uncertainty, we should use that truth […]
Fallibility, Falsifiability, and Critical Rationality
April 5th, 2009 · Comments Off on Fallibility, Falsifiability, and Critical Rationality
Tags: Epistemology/Ontology/Value Theory · Knowledge Making · Knowledge Management
Knowledge and Consensus
February 28th, 2009 · Comments Off on Knowledge and Consensus
Every once in awhile someone in Knowledge Management will state the view that organizational knowledge is the set of beliefs on which there is an organizational consensus. This viewpoint fits with constructivist approaches to knowledge because, according to the constructivists, knowledge comprises the belief filters we humans create to interact with the world, and then […]
Tags: Complexity · Epistemology/Ontology/Value Theory · Knowledge Making
Statements, Beliefs, Justifications, and “the Burden of Proof”
September 2nd, 2008 · 1 Comment
Over the past years, I’ve spent many enjoyable Saturday afternoons participating in Washington, DC’s Cafe Philo group (a face-to-face public philosophy group), and have occasionally participated in its list serv. Over the past couple of days a friend responded to my support of the statement “No statement can be justified,” by asking whether I was: […]
Tags: Epistemology/Ontology/Value Theory · Knowledge Making
Untrue Knowledge
July 17th, 2008 · 4 Comments
Historically, since Plato, the most frequent definition of knowledge has been Justified True Belief (JTB). Until recently (the 20th century), philosophers believed in a foundation for JTB. The Cartesian Rationalists believed that some beliefs were certain because they were self-evident truths that survived Descartes method of doubt. The empiricists believed that some beliefs were self-evident […]
Tags: Epistemology/Ontology/Value Theory · Knowledge Making
Some Comments on Safe-Fail Experiments
May 30th, 2008 · 8 Comments
This post is about “safe-fail experiments.” The essential idea in safe-fail experiments was expressed well by Dave Snowden in this way: “I can afford them to fail and critically, I plan them so that through that failure I learn more about the terrain through which I wish to travel.” And again, in another place, […]
Tags: Complexity · Epistemology/Ontology/Value Theory · Knowledge Making · Knowledge Management